NickSINYC wrote:I actually think Winston is the more talented QB and if he had the personal qualities Mariota has it would be a no brainier for me who I would pick. The problem is he does not.SackExchange wrote:Yeah, I would stay away from Winston. I don't buy into either his leadership or the notion that he makes great reads. He has some Vick in him, in that his physical talent can overcome some mental errors.
I'd take Mariota, Mannion, someone like that over him.
Drafting him would be a boom or bust proposition. I can't see how the team at this point could possibly take that risk. So Mariota is my guy also but coming from his system does make me a little leery even though I still pull the trigger on him.
We're 100%$ in agreement. I feel we're heading into a QB class with Kaepernick and Newton/RG3 sitting at the top of the class, and I don't feel either is a sure thing or a true franchise QB...so we're left with the lesser of two evils and a QB that still isn't Manning, Rodgers, Luck, Brady or Brees...kind of sucks to be honest, but we have to take what we can get I guess.