SackExchange wrote: NYJETSDAN16 wrote: SackExchange wrote:You want to replace Geno with Vick because, why not?
I have no problem putting in Simms. At least then you are gathering data on a young QB. But to me, it seems like you want Geno pulled because you don't like Geno, regardless of what is in the best interests of the organization.
lol, cause i don't like Geno as if we went to junior high and he took my mash pototoes when i was famished on a Wednesday afternoon.
I can't stand him because he is not a starting QB in this league Sack. Mike Vick was. Vick cannot be worse than Smith at this point.
If i strongly didn't want the best interest of the team then i'd vouch to continue with a struggling QB who just doesn't get it. A second rounder for that matter. A second rounder in which the team hasn't really invested much as when they drafted MARK SANCHEZ 5TH OVERALL.
I'am just glad that by this time next year we wont be having this debate on either QB, Sack. Reason being, as long as Geno continues to start and we as fans and the Jets organization can finish "gathering their data" on him, there will be a new coach and a new young 1st round QB leading this team who actually merits the time and development to flourish in the league.
Geno is a lost cause.
So because Sanchez was chosen fifth, and came with a huge contract and investment, he gets four years of worse play. You didn't give up on him until that last season.
Geno doesn't even get 20 games.
And for the record, Geno has been better at this point in his career than Sanchez.
Rookie seasons:
Sanchez - 12 TDs, 20 INTs, 53.8% completions, 2,444 yards, 63.0 passer rating
Geno - 12 TDs, 21 INTs, 55.8% completions, 3,046 yards, 66.5 passer rating
Not to mention Geno this year has a completion percentage above 60% this season (Sanchez never had a season with a 60% completion rate), 4 TDs to 5 INTs (still not a great ratio, but far better than 12/20 or 12/21), and a passer rating of 75.1 at this point (almost identical to Sanchez's 75.3 for his entire second season).
Sanchez was allowed to develop. Geno is not.
This team will never actually develop a franchise QB if no growing pains are never allowed.
That said, I understand why people are frustrated with Geno. But when people gave Sanchez opportunity after opportunity before turning on him, it's hypocritical to want to pull the plug on Geno so quickly.